A man spoke to me about God this afternoon while I was waiting for a friend and I found myself thinking he was wrong. It was all wrong. Yes, I find religion interesting as a concept (how it makes people behave) and I would say I am culturally Christian. I pray occasionally, I like the stories, I find churches somehow comforting. But, amongst other things, the 'Afterlife' bothers me. There are questions I have about it that have no pleasing answer: how old are you in Heaven? I would like to be a child with my parents, old with my grandchildren. If you have loved more than one man, how will they feel about sharing? Won't it be hugely overcrowded and eventually boring? I'm not sure eternity is for me.
I have come to believe that Heaven or Hell is not a place, but the legacy that we leave. If we are happy and well-loved, we live on in beautiful memories and hopefully the lives of those we leave behind, which are better for us being in them.
If you inspire only hate, that is a Hell you've created for yourself.
But this evening I saw a documentary called Hitler's Children. Five descendants of leading members of the Nazi party talking about the guilt that their parents and grandparents have left them.
I have no connection, as far as I'm aware, to anything so horrific but who knows...there have been many atrocities in history, and plenty of time to forget. But I wanted to talk about it for some inexplicable reason. It is one thing to have a million people despise you for your crimes. It is quite another to have your only remaining family have themselves sterilised, as Bettina Goering (niece of the founder of the Gestapo) did, to cut the line that you have tainted. To never have children because they believe anything that comes from you does not deserve to live. Hell, indeed.
But why should they suffer and feel guilt? Each new person is a new slate aren't they?
But we are told so often how like our parents we are. And not just our faces. Sometimes we inherit a temper, or a stubborn streak. What is it like to fear you could be capable of the same crimes? The same blindness?
Niklas Frank, another of the 'children' has spent most of his adult life chronicling, condemning and telling the world about his father, a monster. But the thing I found most painful was not the fact that Frank felt he had to remind people so it didn't happen again, it wasn't that he needed to punish himself daily by recounting his own childhood memories and experiences of genocide, it was when he revealed that he continued to research because he was looking for one redeeming feature of his father, one life saved or spared, so that he could love his own flesh and blood. He found nothing.
But, there was love too. His daughter never had to fight her past because he has 'already defeated it' for her. And forgiveness as Auchwitz's commander's grandson returned there to be told by a survivor of the camp to stop blaming himself: "you were not there."
As I said, I know nothing of this. I'm highly unqualified to tackle the issue but I wanted to share with you this terribly poignant pragramme. I have no moral to share because I don't know what it should be. Love? Being good? Forgive and forget or remember and learn? Sometimes, a subject raises more questions than it answers, and the twisted, fragile and contrary nature of the human conscious is certainly one them.